Tolkien Gateway

An Introduction to Elvish

Revision as of 12:49, 17 February 2009 by Sage (Talk | contribs)
An Introduction to Elvish
AuthorJim Allan (ed)
PublisherBran's Head
ReleasedJanuary 1978

An Introduction to Elvish and to Other Tongues, Proper Names and Writing Systems of the Third Age of the Western Lands of Middle-Earth as Set Forth in the Published Writings of Professor John Ronald Reuel Tolkien was a book by Jim Allan that discussed the languages of Middle-earth.

The book was comprised by various articles written by members of the Mythopoeic Society and its publication was authorized by the Mythopoeic Linguistic Fellowship (a forerunner of the Elvish Linguistic Fellowship).



Eldarin tongues

The first articles offer analyses of the Elvish texts published and extrapolation of grammar and meaning of the names found in the books. There is also a chapter that goes on to discuss the relationship of Quenya and Sindarin and analyze a possible Proto-Eldarin, even 10 years before the publication of the Etymologies or other texts where Tolkien clearly discusses Primitive Quendian.

The chapters are followed by glossaries pointing at possible real-word similarities.

An article written from Tolkien's secondary world perspective, explain how Elvish possibly influenced the Indo-European languages.

Other tongues

More obscure languages like Khuzdul, Black Speech, "Adunaic tongues" and more obscure ones (Westron, Mannish, Entish, "Valinorean") are also briefly discussed. Their sources are primarily information as given in the Appendices.

Personal names

A part of the book provides etymologies of the Old English, Gothic and Norse words and names used by Tolkien for Mannish languages such as Westron and Rohirric; possible influences from British and Celtic folklore are pointed out. There is also a "Baby-book" with all the known real-world ("translated") Hobbit names by category, along with their etymologies.

Writing systems

There is also an analysis of the Tengwar and Cirth in an extensive chapter which aims to be more clear and readable presentation of the information of Appendix E, followed by a possible history of their evolution, theoretical and structural analysis and examples of English-tengwar texts used by fans. Also, an article points out similarities between Francis Lodwick's "Universal Alphabet" and Tengwar.

Sources and validity

The material of that time came only from the works published during Tolkien's lifetime: The Hobbit, The Lord of the Rings, The Adventures of Tom Bombadil, The Road Goes Ever On and Guide to the Names in The Lord of the Rings

The book was complete in 1977 but publication was halted for a year. The Silmarillion was published in the meantime which included new material that (in few points) obsoleted the theories of the book. These are taken into consideration in the postscript of the Foreword by Jim Allan, edited a year later, before first publication; he points out that updating the text by incorporating them in it, would not be possible, and encourages critical comparison by the reader.

Since 1977, a great amount of material was published in the History of Middle-earth series, not to mention magazines such as Vinyar Tengwar and Parma Eldalamberon; while the fans consent that the book is one of the best and more serious works[1], new material renders the theories incomplete or outdated. In reality some of its parts, like the one concerning real-world names and the writing systems, still provide useful information.