Tolkien Gateway

Forum:Database Lock

Revision as of 21:48, 21 June 2010 by KingAragorn (Talk | contribs)
Tolkien Gateway > Council > Database Lock


First off, I want to thank everyone for reverting all the spam edits and tagging false pages for deletion.

The spam we've had this past months is hard to miss. And it seems endless. So, in a small (and frankly, one-sided) discussion, three users expressed the interest in locking the database for all unregistered users (perhaps only temporary), arguing that the little contributions we get from anons is a small loss compared to the gain of stopping the spam dead.

But me being Dutch and all (and one of the Dutch mantra's is "discussing without deciding is better than deciding without discussing"), want to put up a vote.

Considering the need for a decision, vote before Wednesday, June 23, 18:00 UTC.

The Database Should Be Locked To Unregistered Users

Support
  1. Ederchil (Talk/Contribs/Edits)
  2. Mith (Talk/Contribs/Edits)
  3. User:Morgan
Information
Heraldic Device of Eärendil and his House.
lore-2 This user has an intermediate understanding of J.R.R. Tolkien's works.
Hobbit This user supports Hobbits over any other race.
Ent This user believes the Entwives are lost forever.
Olanda Fong-Surdenas - The Balrog of Moria.jpg This user believes Balrogs do not have wings.

Hi all!

My on-line name is Earendilyon. I've known Tolkien's writings since the late '80s and have most of his work in my possession, and a lot about him and/or about his writings.

Other interests of mine are:

  • (Medieval) History (I've got an MA in it)
  • Languages (especially Latin)
  • Hiking
  • Reading

--Earendilyon 04:59, 8 February 2006 (EST)

My Tolkien Library

Books by Tolkien:

  1. The Book of Lost Tales Part One
  2. The Book of Lost Tales Part Two
  3. The Lays of Beleriand
  4. The Shaping of Middle-earth
  5. The Lost Road and Other Writings
  6. The Return of the Shadow
  7. The Treason of Isengard
  8. The War of the Ring
  9. Sauron Defeated
  10. Morgoth's Ring
  11. The War of the Jewels
  12. The Peoples of Middle-earth

Books about Tolkien:

  1.  KingAragorn  talk  contribs  edits  email  21:48, 21 June 2010 (UTC)
Arguments in Support:
  • It stops the spambots cold.
  • Therefore, it doesn't ruin Recent Changes and Page History any longer.
  • Furthermore, it would prevent the wrecking (if only temporarily) of articles.
  • The effort of reverting and deleting the pages is time consuming and really, really works on my nerves.
  • Anonymous edits these past months haven't really been good edits, or are edits that wouldn't be missed.
Oppose
Arguments in Opposition:
  • It prevents anonymous edits, some of which are useful.
  • It could discourage editors signing-up (as some users edit anonymously before joining) at a time when the Gateway needs more editors.
  • It could, as a result, make the Tolkien Gateway are more insular and closed community.