Tolkien Gateway

Forum:Multiple title redirects

(Difference between revisions)
m (Just corrected the spelling on the internal link)
Line 15: Line 15:
  
 
::I'm stumped on this one as I could sway either way. One thing we have to consider though is at some point I would like to expand into [[Sindarin]] and [[Quenya]] articles. Where we would have an article for ''alahasta'' which simply would state it is a noun, is found on X pg. in X book and means unmarred in Quenya. With this project in mind it ''does'' make more sense to go the no-redirect route. --[[User:Hyarion|Hyarion]] 14:17, 28 April 2006 (EDT)
 
::I'm stumped on this one as I could sway either way. One thing we have to consider though is at some point I would like to expand into [[Sindarin]] and [[Quenya]] articles. Where we would have an article for ''alahasta'' which simply would state it is a noun, is found on X pg. in X book and means unmarred in Quenya. With this project in mind it ''does'' make more sense to go the no-redirect route. --[[User:Hyarion|Hyarion]] 14:17, 28 April 2006 (EDT)
 +
 +
:Would [[Mardil]] be a good example of the type of entry that ''should'' be redirected in a "semi-redirection" approach? --[[User:Ebakunin|Ebakunin]] 20:28, 3 May 2006 (EDT)

Revision as of 00:28, 4 May 2006

Tolkien Gateway > Council > Multiple title redirects


With most of J.R.R. Tolkien's works there are characters with more than one title. This becomes a problem with a few suggested solutions we can vote on:

  • Redirection - We can redirect all titles to one main article which we vote can vote on if there is not an obvious choice. The determination for the title will be the subject of another topic as we would have to take into consideration what was used the most, what is most canonical, and what is most proper, etc. The upside to this concept would be people can find all information on that character on one page. The downside is they might have trouble finding information on the specific lesser title for the character when they are redirected there. An example being if someone wanted to find why Aragorn was known as Strider, and it redirects to Aragorn II, this might not be very efficient.
  • No redirection - In this scenario every instance of every name has its own page with information on that title and character. The Strider article would contain information when Aragorn was known as Strider, when he beceame known as Aragorn Elessar, that article would fill in those details.
  • Semi-redirection - With this option all content is kept on one page but each different title of the character has its own page as well which contains information on what the title means. This is kind of a combination of the two earlier choices.
--Hyarion 00:03, 28 April 2006 (EDT)


I'd go for the last one: all info in the article with the most used name, the info on the specific nick names in seperate articles with a link to the chief article. Even Túrin-with-the-many-names is mostly known as Túrin Turambar. --Earendilyon 01:52, 28 April 2006 (EDT)

Perhaps it would be good to Redirect and include an "other names" section at the bottom. --Narfil Palùrfalas 10:02, 28 April 2006 (EDT)
I'm stumped on this one as I could sway either way. One thing we have to consider though is at some point I would like to expand into Sindarin and Quenya articles. Where we would have an article for alahasta which simply would state it is a noun, is found on X pg. in X book and means unmarred in Quenya. With this project in mind it does make more sense to go the no-redirect route. --Hyarion 14:17, 28 April 2006 (EDT)
Would Mardil be a good example of the type of entry that should be redirected in a "semi-redirection" approach? --Ebakunin 20:28, 3 May 2006 (EDT)