Forum:Orcs creation theory
This may have already been covered, but i was thinking, since Yavanna sung about ents and they were made by Eru, and Manwe sung about eagles and were produced, maybe Morgoth sung about Orcs in the Music of the Ainur, and though it may sound bad Eru created them because as he proclaimed during the music
"Eru then publicly rebuked Melkor, saying that all music found its source in himself, and thus Melkor could not create his own song or truly alter the Themes of Ilúvatar. Thus, though Melkor opposed Eru to his last breath, he only furthered the cause of Ilúvatar in new and wondrous ways"
Thoughts?Flame of Anor 07:36, 1 June 2009 (UTC)
It's an interesting thought, and a possible theory; however the most commonly accepted theory is that the Orcs were created by Morgoth through the torture and mutilation of Elves. Still, it is never absolutely confirmed, so your theory might well be correct. You've come up with a good analysis of the text!--18:39, 31 May 2009 (UTC)
Also, since Fea (the flame imperishable) is given by Eru, the first orcs could be corrupted Elves, because the elves had Fea to begin with. But why would Eru continue to give the next and following generations of Orcs Hroa (body) Fea. Therefore, orcs could be formed from the song of Morgoth and Eru could have given them Fea because they serve a purpose in the grand scheme of Eru, as do the Eagles and Ents.Flame of Anor 07:46, 1 June 2009 (UTC)
Any more ideas Flame of Anor
Tolkien never made up his mind for good about the creation of orcs, and while I've seen a number of very interesting theories none of them is any better than any other given our knowledge at the present time (which is not likely to change).
That said, Tolkien did have some interesting musings in Texts VII and VIII of "Myths Transformed", which can be found in _The History of Middle-earth X: Morgoth's Ring_. He posits that Orcs did fëar (souls). He also considers the possibility of the music being the source of Orcs as it was the source of other evils, but he goes on to suggest otherwise.
I hope that did more clarification than confusion. :) Eldorion
I can understand the first creation and mutilation of Orcs into Elves, or Melkor's song of a short (stunted), elf-like species (Hobbits?) that was twisted with Melkor into evil, but after the first few were created, how did they reproduce? I never heard of a female Orc.--Galdor of the Havens 21:19, 10 December 2009 (UTC)