Giants: Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
m (;) wrong vowel) |
||
Line 11: | Line 11: | ||
Given these facts, it does not seem far-fetched that the reference to 'stone-giants' is analogous to 'stone-Ents': some group of [[Ents|Ent]] that has an affinity for, or is charged with the upkeep of, mountains rather than forests. The difference in terminology being similar to the interchangeable uses of ''[[goblin]]'' and ''[[orc]]''. That such a group would endanger travellers by throwing boulders fits with the detached attitude towards other inhabitants of Middle-earth Ents are known to have. However Gandalf's suggestion that they find a friendly Giant/Ent to help them reflects his knowledge that Ents are a fundamentally good race. | Given these facts, it does not seem far-fetched that the reference to 'stone-giants' is analogous to 'stone-Ents': some group of [[Ents|Ent]] that has an affinity for, or is charged with the upkeep of, mountains rather than forests. The difference in terminology being similar to the interchangeable uses of ''[[goblin]]'' and ''[[orc]]''. That such a group would endanger travellers by throwing boulders fits with the detached attitude towards other inhabitants of Middle-earth Ents are known to have. However Gandalf's suggestion that they find a friendly Giant/Ent to help them reflects his knowledge that Ents are a fundamentally good race. | ||
Another possibility, given that mountain-dwelling [[Trolls]] are described by [[Treebeard]] as an evil mockery of Ents (as Orcs to Elves), the Giants of the Misty Mountains could be a mix between the two. As [[Saruman]] bred Men and Orcs, it is feasible that in an early experiment Saruman (who had dealings with the Ents of Fangorn) or an older power such as [[Angmar]] or [[Dol | Another possibility, given that mountain-dwelling [[Trolls]] are described by [[Treebeard]] as an evil mockery of Ents (as Orcs to Elves), the Giants of the Misty Mountains could be a mix between the two. As [[Saruman]] bred Men and Orcs, it is feasible that in an early experiment Saruman (who had dealings with the Ents of Fangorn) or an older power such as [[Angmar]] or [[Dol Guldur]] bred Ents and Trolls creating the Giants which remain in the Misty Mountains. | ||
[[Category:Races]] | [[Category:Races]] |
Revision as of 19:27, 9 February 2008
Giants were perhaps the most mysterious of the Races of Middle-earth, Giants are mentioned only fleetingly by Tolkien, but sufficiently often to show that they did exist in his world. They lived in the Misty Mountains, and maybe the Ettenmoors.
The only sign of Giants that is definite happened during the Quest of Erebor, when Bilbo and the Dwarves were traveling through the Misty Mountains. This could just be a figure of speech, for there was also a thunderstorm at the time, and that could have been causing the rocks to fall. Bilbo said that this was the act of Giants:
across the valley the stone-giants were out, and were hurling rocks at one another for a game...
That is fairly unlikely, though. The Dwarves, Bilbo, and even Gandalf act as if the Giants are real. Thorin Oakenshield is even worried about being picked up by one, and Gandalf, the wisest one there, suggests that they find a friendly Giant to deal with the Goblin problem in the Misty Mountains.
It is possible that the Giants of the Misty Mountains are some form of Ent, Tolkien having derived the word Ent from the Anglo-Saxon for Giant. Ents are indeed described as something close to the common conception of a Giant ("a large Man-like, almost Troll-like, figure, at least fourteen foot high, very sturdy, with a tall head, and hardly any neck."). Their ability to tear rock "...like bread-crust." and hurl huge boulders is described by Tolkien when the Ents of Fangorn attack Isenguard. Individual Ents are also known to vary greatly among themselves, and some are said to be full of anger and hate.
Given these facts, it does not seem far-fetched that the reference to 'stone-giants' is analogous to 'stone-Ents': some group of Ent that has an affinity for, or is charged with the upkeep of, mountains rather than forests. The difference in terminology being similar to the interchangeable uses of goblin and orc. That such a group would endanger travellers by throwing boulders fits with the detached attitude towards other inhabitants of Middle-earth Ents are known to have. However Gandalf's suggestion that they find a friendly Giant/Ent to help them reflects his knowledge that Ents are a fundamentally good race.
Another possibility, given that mountain-dwelling Trolls are described by Treebeard as an evil mockery of Ents (as Orcs to Elves), the Giants of the Misty Mountains could be a mix between the two. As Saruman bred Men and Orcs, it is feasible that in an early experiment Saruman (who had dealings with the Ents of Fangorn) or an older power such as Angmar or Dol Guldur bred Ents and Trolls creating the Giants which remain in the Misty Mountains.