Tolkien Gateway

Global Theory

(Difference between revisions)
(New page: '''Global Theory''' is a theory by Eduard J. Kloczko according to which, all of Tolkien's work can be understood as a single continuity, no matter the inconsistencies or alterations. ...)
 
 
(8 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
'''Global Theory''' is a theory by [[Eduard J. Kloczko]] according to which, all of Tolkien's work can be understood as a single continuity, no matter the inconsistencies or alterations.
+
'''Global Theory''' is an alternative way of understanding Tolkien's [[legendarium]] suggested by [[David Giraudeau]] after a concept by [[Edouard Kloczko]].  
  
The theory is an alternative way of understanding Tolkien's [[legendarium]], having in mind both his early mythological works (eg. [[Book of Lost Tales]]) and the later ([[Lord of the Rings]]). For example the ''BoLT'' is understood as happened in the middle ages, long after the happenings of the books, and the [[Qenya]] and [[Goldogrin]] words and names are medieval evolution of the "earlier" [[Quenya]] and [[Sindarin]] of the [[Elder Days]].
+
According to this theory, all of Tolkien's work can be understood as a single continuity, no matter the inconsistencies or alterations, having in mind both his early mythological works (eg. ''[[The Book of Lost Tales Part One]]'') and the later (''[[The Lord of the Rings]]'').  
 +
 
 +
For example the theory suggests that the ''Book of Lost Tales'' should be understood to have happened in the Middle Ages, long after the prehistorical happenings of the books; the [[Qenya]] and [[Gnomish|Goldogrin]] words and names are medieval evolution of the "earlier" [[Quenya]] and [[Sindarin]] of the [[Elder Days]].
  
 
All inconsistencies can be dismissed by crediting them to errors or misunderstandings of the copyists, including [[Eriol]].
 
All inconsistencies can be dismissed by crediting them to errors or misunderstandings of the copyists, including [[Eriol]].

Latest revision as of 05:42, 23 October 2012

Global Theory is an alternative way of understanding Tolkien's legendarium suggested by David Giraudeau after a concept by Edouard Kloczko.

According to this theory, all of Tolkien's work can be understood as a single continuity, no matter the inconsistencies or alterations, having in mind both his early mythological works (eg. The Book of Lost Tales Part One) and the later (The Lord of the Rings).

For example the theory suggests that the Book of Lost Tales should be understood to have happened in the Middle Ages, long after the prehistorical happenings of the books; the Qenya and Goldogrin words and names are medieval evolution of the "earlier" Quenya and Sindarin of the Elder Days.

All inconsistencies can be dismissed by crediting them to errors or misunderstandings of the copyists, including Eriol.

[edit] External links

  • Essay by David Giraudeau