Mannish: Difference between revisions

From Tolkien Gateway
No edit summary
Line 12: Line 12:
==Schematic==
==Schematic==
Note that many all showed influence by Avarin tongues as well as [[Khuzdul]]:
Note that many all showed influence by Avarin tongues as well as [[Khuzdul]]:
#*Languages of forefathers of the First and Third Houses of the [[Atanatári]]
*Languages of the First and Third Houses of the [[Atanatári]]
#**[[Taliska]] (two dialects)
**[[Taliska]] (two dialects; Beor and Hador)
#***[[Adûnaic]]
***[[Adûnaic]]
#****[[Westron]] or "Common Speech" (influenced by [[Sindarin]], and languages of [[Eriador]])
****[[Westron]] or "Common Speech" (influenced by [[Sindarin]], and languages of [[Eriador]])
#*****[[Hobbit]]ish (influenced by languages of [[Northmen]])
*****[[Hobbit]]ish (influenced by languages of [[Northmen]])
#****Black Adûnaic of [[Black Númenóreans]]
****Black Adûnaic of [[Black Númenóreans]]
#**Languages of Men of [[Eriador]] during the [[Second Age]]
**Languages of Men of [[Eriador]] during the [[Second Age]]
#**Languages of [[Northmen]]
**Languages of [[Northmen]]
#***[[Dalish]]
***[[Dalish]]
#***[[Rohirric]]
***[[Rohirric]]
#*Language of forefathers of the Second House of the Atanatári
*Language of the Second House of the Atanatári
#**[[Haladin]] language
**[[Haladin]] language
#**[[Dunlending]]
**[[Dunlending]]
#*[[Drûg]] languages
*[[Drûg]] languages
#**Language of the Drúedain of [[Brethil]]
**Language of the Drúedain of [[Brethil]]
#**Language of the Woses of [[Drúadan forest]]
**Language of the Woses of [[Drúadan forest]]
#*Many [[Harad]]rim languages
*Many [[Harad]]rim languages
#*Many tongues of [[Easterlings]]
*Many tongues of [[Easterlings]]
 
==Translation==
==Translation==
Tolkien used real-life languages and names to present Mannish. The most known example is Westron, which is always replaced with modern English.  
Tolkien used real-life languages and names to present Mannish. The most known example is Westron, which is always replaced with modern English.  

Revision as of 11:00, 29 December 2008

A term to refer to the languages of Men, as opposed to the Elvish tongues, or those of the other races of Middle-earth. By far the most prominent Mannish languageis Westron, also called the Common Speech.

History

Languages of Men started in Hildórien. When the Edain divided to migrate to the west. The groups that would eventually be known as House of Bëor and House of Marach, used one language. The third tribe, that wold be later known as the House of Haleth, used an unrelated tongue.

During the march, the tribes left behind various descendants in Eriador who continued their languages. In Beleriand the House of Beor quickly adopted Sindarin. However the language of Hador retained and was influenced by Khuzdul[1]

The language of the House of Hador during the Second Age evolved into Adûnaic. [2] Meanwhile the descendants of the First Age in the Westlands became the Éothéod from whom ultimately derives the Rohirric language. The language of the House of Haleth also left descendants such as Dunlandish.

Early Adûnaic mingled with many words of the languages of lesser men and became a Common Speech that spread thence along the coasts among all that had dealings with Westernesse[3].

After the Downfall, the faithful considered Sindarin their mother tongue and used the Common Speech in their dealings with other folk and in the government of their wide realms; but they enlarged the language and enriched it with many words drawn from the Elven-tongues.[3].

Schematic

Note that many all showed influence by Avarin tongues as well as Khuzdul:

Translation

Tolkien used real-life languages and names to present Mannish. The most known example is Westron, which is always replaced with modern English.

This logic went one step further by also presenting all languages akin to Westron in languages related to English, so that their "understandability" by the protagonists is simulated to the English reader. Since English belongs to the germanic family, most names Tolkien uses are germanic (Norse, Gothic etc) with some celtic exceptions.

  • Rohirric, the language of the Rohirrim was replaced by Anglo-Saxon, as Rohirric is an archaic relative of Westron, much as Anglo-Saxon is an archaic relative of English;
  • The tongue of Dale (from which came the names of the Dwarves of Durin's Folk), was translated into Old Norse, a language related to Anglo-Saxon and modern English as Dalish was related to Rohirric and Westron;
  • The hobbit names of the Stoors, Buckland as well as some Bree-land names are Celtic;
  • Few "heathen" names related to Rhovanion (such as "Vidugavia") are Gothic, indicating a relationship to Dalish but not recognisable by Westron.

Mannish languages unrelated to Westron that sounded alien to the protagonists, were left in their "genuine" form.

External links

  1. "Of Dwarves and Men", in: The Peoples of Middle earth
  2. Notion Club Papers
  3. 3.0 3.1 Appendix F in: The Return of the King