Tolkien Gateway

Tomatoes

(Difference between revisions)
m (Tomatoes are non-canon?!)
m (Added information and references)
 
Line 3: Line 3:
 
'''Tomatoes''' were supposedly a plant known to the [[Hobbits]].  
 
'''Tomatoes''' were supposedly a plant known to the [[Hobbits]].  
  
They were referenced in the first edition of ''[[The Hobbit]]'', but Tolkien changed this to "pickles" in the second edition since the American plantlife would not fit in his setting of ancient [[Middle-earth]]; however see [[potatoes]] and [[pipe-weed]].
+
They were referenced in the first edition of ''[[The Hobbit]]'',<ref>{{HH|Bladorthin}}, p. 34</ref> but [[J.R.R. Tolkien]] changed this to "pickles" in the third edition (1966).<ref>{{HH|Bladorthin}}, note 11, p. 43</ref>  The most usual explanation for the change is that the American plant-life would not fit in his setting of ancient [[Middle-earth]].  However, as pointed out by [[John D. Rateliff]], it may have been simply that Tolkien felt that it was too early in the year for tomatoes and substituted a preserved food instead.<ref>{{HH|NC1}}, note 18, p. 18</ref>
 +
 
 +
==See Also==
 +
* [[potatoes]]
 +
* [[pipe-weed]]
 +
 
 +
{{references}}
 
[[category:Plants]]
 
[[category:Plants]]

Latest revision as of 21:35, 28 June 2012

"there are Tolkien's latest thoughts, his best thoughts, and his published thoughts and these are not necessarily the same." — Tolkien's Legendarium
This article is non-canon.
"And just bring out the cold chicken and tomatoes!"
Gandalf to Bilbo Baggins, An Unexpected Party

Tomatoes were supposedly a plant known to the Hobbits.

They were referenced in the first edition of The Hobbit,[1] but J.R.R. Tolkien changed this to "pickles" in the third edition (1966).[2] The most usual explanation for the change is that the American plant-life would not fit in his setting of ancient Middle-earth. However, as pointed out by John D. Rateliff, it may have been simply that Tolkien felt that it was too early in the year for tomatoes and substituted a preserved food instead.[3]

[edit] See Also

[edit] References

  1. J.R.R. Tolkien, John D. Rateliff (ed.), The History of The Hobbit, Mr. Baggins, The First Phase, "The Bladorthin Typescript", p. 34
  2. J.R.R. Tolkien, John D. Rateliff (ed.), The History of The Hobbit, Mr. Baggins, The First Phase, "The Bladorthin Typescript", note 11, p. 43
  3. J.R.R. Tolkien, John D. Rateliff (ed.), The History of The Hobbit, Return to Bag-End, "The Fifth Phase", "New Chapter I. A Well-Planned Party", note 18, p. 18