User talk:Ederchil: Difference between revisions
From Tolkien Gateway
Latest comment: 9 January 2009 by Ederchil in topic Carn Dum
No edit summary |
(→Things: new section) |
||
| Line 33: | Line 33: | ||
:Well, at first I disagreed, but with the current reword it's fine. I removed the phrase "The circumflex ^ is used by Tolkien in Sindarin extra long vowels[2], but these words have not been attested in Sindarin." because there are plenty of those in Sindarin, even with the û - Udûn, for one. But properly sourced, it's good. Note that we're still working on referencing, but we pretty much agreed on [[User:Ederchil/Sandbox#LotR|these]]. Keep up the work - don't be shy, go ahead and completely rewrite an article instead of adding a couple of sentences if you think it needs it. Even very minor characters like [[Gildor Inglorion]] or even [[Nob]] could have a very good article. -- {{User:Ederchil/sig}} 09:23, 9 January 2009 (UTC) | :Well, at first I disagreed, but with the current reword it's fine. I removed the phrase "The circumflex ^ is used by Tolkien in Sindarin extra long vowels[2], but these words have not been attested in Sindarin." because there are plenty of those in Sindarin, even with the û - Udûn, for one. But properly sourced, it's good. Note that we're still working on referencing, but we pretty much agreed on [[User:Ederchil/Sandbox#LotR|these]]. Keep up the work - don't be shy, go ahead and completely rewrite an article instead of adding a couple of sentences if you think it needs it. Even very minor characters like [[Gildor Inglorion]] or even [[Nob]] could have a very good article. -- {{User:Ederchil/sig}} 09:23, 9 January 2009 (UTC) | ||
== Things == | |||
How do you get those little boxes and such that say your name and have links to talk, profile, etc.? | |||
Revision as of 23:41, 20 January 2009
 |
Welcome to Ederchil's talk page. |
|
Archive
2008
In which:
- Hyarion welcomes me, invites me for the chat, discusses the Calendar, and asks my opinion on the Ithilien skin.
- Earendilyon comments on Uyldert's schotschrift.
- Sigismond plays Brühl tourguide, and discusses a proper translation of etwas vereinheitlichen.
- Quidon88 has cousins over, and discusses a wanted page.
- Mithrennaith, Earendilyon and yours sincerely have a gezelli semi-Dutch/semi-English conversation about redirects.
- Theoden1 doesn't like my self-nomination of Glamdring for FA, and rightly so.
- As a result of my very first Welcome!, Þelma ends up on my Talk Page rather than Hyarion's.
- Theoden1 doesn't like me dogpiling, and rightly so.
- Bohwe likes me liking her art.
- Sage discusses the faults in the Tale of Years and In-Universe/Out-of-Universe.
- KingAragorn and Theoden1 urge me to accept my Admin nomination.
- Þelma and Mithrennaith discuss the proper usage of "Prince".
- Mithrennaith throws in a bucket of The Netherlands related messages.
- Quidon88 and Hyarion discuss games as part of Adaptations with me.
- User:Ingwe wants his desriptions back in Garland's pics.
- User:Hyarion and User:Theoden1 check out of meetings.
- User:Numenorian (sic) sics.
- User:Aule the Smith discusses Windows.
- User:Breragor is lost in wiki-lingo.
- User:Sage discusses dates. No, not that kind.
Carn Dum
Hi, what did you not like in that article's analysis? shouldn't we mention that the name can be Sindarin, and if so, we don't know the words? Temp 08:54, 9 January 2009 (UTC)
- Well, at first I disagreed, but with the current reword it's fine. I removed the phrase "The circumflex ^ is used by Tolkien in Sindarin extra long vowels[2], but these words have not been attested in Sindarin." because there are plenty of those in Sindarin, even with the û - Udûn, for one. But properly sourced, it's good. Note that we're still working on referencing, but we pretty much agreed on these. Keep up the work - don't be shy, go ahead and completely rewrite an article instead of adding a couple of sentences if you think it needs it. Even very minor characters like Gildor Inglorion or even Nob could have a very good article. -- Ederchil (Talk/Contribs/Edits) 09:23, 9 January 2009 (UTC)
Things
How do you get those little boxes and such that say your name and have links to talk, profile, etc.?
