User contributions for 82.71.104.222
From Tolkien Gateway
6 July 2020
- 14:3614:36, 6 July 2020 diff hist +113 Glorfindel →Re-embodiment and Return: This is a bit too emphatic about one preferred date for his return, there are arguments for all three.
31 July 2019
- 14:4314:43, 31 July 2019 diff hist +1,147 Glorfindel There was no mention of Glorfindel in Aredhel's escort, so I copied that section from the Ecthelion page.
10 January 2019
- 18:3018:30, 10 January 2019 diff hist +259 Losgar fixed a typo and clarifed that Fingolfin chose the Helcaraxe, not Feanor.
9 January 2019
- 09:2809:28, 9 January 2019 diff hist −4 Galadriel →Life in Aman: whether the Doom of Mandos is a prophecy, a judgement, or a curse is controversial. Safer to refer to 'Doom' as the TG entry does, than declare it a prophesy in passing.
7 July 2018
- 22:1322:13, 7 July 2018 diff hist −122 Curufin →Flight of the Noldor: the statement that Celebrimbor disliked his father's 'deviousness' was, I believe, 100% fanon, and was completely unreferenced. I removed it.
19 March 2018
- 12:4012:40, 19 March 2018 diff hist +9 Curufin →Life in Beleriand: wording about Finrod's oath was rather confused and misleading.
10 March 2018
- 14:5414:54, 10 March 2018 diff hist +154 House of Elros adding a line to make it clear which editions of UT include the The earlier generations of the Line of Elros as this is missing from many editions
9 March 2018
- 17:4717:47, 9 March 2018 diff hist +273 Elros Added a note about where the names of Tindómiel, Manwendil and Atanalcar come from, since multiple editions of Unfinished Tales do not show the 'chart' referenced.
6 January 2018
- 19:2319:23, 6 January 2018 diff hist +84 Timeline/First Age It's confusing that Brithombar & Eglarest are mentioned as constructed but not when they were ruined. Added that.
16 December 2017
- 13:4113:41, 16 December 2017 diff hist −27 Timeline →Years of the Trees: removed mention of death of Amrod, at this period, not mentioned in the Silmarillion and inconsistent with it, but very briefly as a 'dark legend' in HoME
20 September 2017
- 08:3408:34, 20 September 2017 diff hist −70 Isle of Balar Removed the sentence about Balar surviving the War of Wrath: this is speculation.
18 June 2017
- 14:1914:19, 18 June 2017 diff hist −313 Finarfin Removed a very confused line about Feanor & Amras (Feanor did canonically learn to speak the Sindarin of Hithlum, so it was also wrong).
28 March 2017
- 05:4105:41, 28 March 2017 diff hist +26 Timeline/First Age Timeline omitted Silmarillion-canonical death of Amrod at Havens of Sirion.
29 January 2017
- 17:3717:37, 29 January 2017 diff hist −126 Palantíri →Origin and early history: I've taken out the section about the Palantiri being gifts of Gil-galad. This is not referenced, and I can't find a source for it. The sources I checked just say 'gifts of the Eldar'.
6 November 2016
- 18:4618:46, 6 November 2016 diff hist +33 Aegnor →History: Aegnor's death cannot have brought about the Athrabeth, because Aegnor died in the Dagor Bragollach, in 455, and the Athrabeth is dated 409. Andreth was born 361 and was mortal, she can't have been talking to Finrod after 455.
12 August 2015
- 13:4713:47, 12 August 2015 diff hist −1 Elven life cycle →Sexuality, marriage and parenthood
- 13:4413:44, 12 August 2015 diff hist +406 Elven life cycle →Sexuality, marriage and parenthood
28 June 2015
- 22:2722:27, 28 June 2015 diff hist −51 Nirnaeth Arnoediad →The Battle