https://tolkiengateway.net/w/api.php?action=feedcontributions&feedformat=atom&user=66.65.42.95 2026-06-06T00:38:40Z User contributions MediaWiki 1.41.1 https://tolkiengateway.net/w/index.php?title=User_talk:Hyarion/Reviews/Ringers:_Lord_of_the_Fans&diff=8076 2005-12-04T06:44:17Z

<p>66.65.42.95: Good points</p> <hr /> <div>I agree with the bits about it being too one-sided with info we already know. And the part you said about it being too heavy with celebrities is also true.<br /> I did want to see more QUALITY fan interviews--they seemed to be all about really mundane things that we really know already. I mean, if i were to explain why i loved LotR so much i would also go with Tolkien and his backstory of why he wrote it and why we NEED an uplifting story about good versus bad in this world.<br /> It was kind of repetitious about stuff we already know which was kind of like &quot;selling LotR&quot; for us again and i didn't like that part of it at all.<br /> You have some solid points but i did enjoy the documentary as a whole and was really happy with it. It has its shortcomings but it's still good to see other fans obsess about LotR as much as i do....<br /> I'll write more when i read your whole review--i like what i see in the first half though so thanks for sharing.</div>

66.65.42.95