Bindbole Wood: Difference between revisions

From Tolkien Gateway
m (added {{references}} and removed html code)
 
(9 intermediate revisions by 6 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
'''Bindbole Wood''' was a small wood in the southern part of the [[Northfarthing]] in the [[Shire]].
'''Bindbole Wood''' was a small wood in the southern part of the [[Northfarthing]] in [[the Shire]].<ref>{{FR|Part}}</ref>
==Etymology==
The name presumably contains ''bind'' and ''[[Wiktionary:bole#Etymology_1|bole]]'' "trunk of a tree".<ref name=etym>{{webcite|author=[[David Salo]]|articleurl=https://tolkienlistsearch.herokuapp.com/message/5e9c35b63ee6a6c41e9862d6|articlename=Hobbitish Place-names (1.21)|dated=23 November 1998|website=[[Elfling]]|accessed=9 October 2014}}</ref>
===Misspelling===
The name appears in the map of the Shire, but the letter ''o'' in the 1954 edition was not very clear; thus the name has been rendered '''Bindbale''' in many later maps (e.g. by [[Barbara Strachey]] and [[Karen Wynn Fonstad]]), and elsewhere, like in [[Robert Foster]]'s ''[[The Complete Guide to Middle-earth]]'' (s.v. ''Bindbale'').


The name appears in the map of the Shire, but the letter ''o'' n the 1954 edition was not very clear; thus the name has been rendered '''Bindbale''' in many later maps (e.g. by [[Barbara Strachey]] and [[Karen Wynn Fonstad]]), and elsewhere, like in [[Robert Foster]]'s ''[[The Complete Guide to Middle-earth]]'' (s.v. ''Bindbale'').
Even Tolkien himself referred to ''Bindbale'' in a manuscript note when he was preparing the document later known as ''[[Guide to the Names in The Lord of the Rings|Nomenclature]]'' (Hammond and Scull suggest that perhaps writing this, Tolkien referred to the printed map and fell victim too of the misprinted ''o''); as a result, in dutch it was translated (after Tolkien's suggestion) as ''Pakkebaal Bos'' which includes ''[[Wiktionary:baal#Dutch|baal]]'' "b'''a'''le".<ref name=rc/><ref name=rc>{{HM|RC}}, p. lvii</ref>
 
Even Tolkien himself referred to ''Bindbale'' in a manuscript note when he was preparing the document later known as ''[[Guide to the Names in The Lord of the Rings|Nomenclature]]''.<ref>[[Wayne G. Hammond]], [[Christina Scull]] (2008), ''[[The Lord of the Rings: A Reader's Companion]]'', p. lvii</ref>


==Inspiration==
[[Christopher Tolkien]] would reminisce that there is an actual English place named "Bindbole Wood", being one of the real place-names borrowed while drawing ''[[A Part of the Shire]]'' map with his father. However this must be a [[Wikipedia:false memory|false memory]] as there is no trace of such a place, not even Christopher himself was able to find any information afterwards.<ref name=rc/>
{{references}}
{{references}}


[[Category:Forests]]
[[Category:Forests]]
[[Category:Shire]]
[[Category:The Shire]]


[[de:Schiefertonwald]]
[[de:Schiefertonwald]]
[[fi:Palokorpi]]
[[fi:Palokorpi]]

Latest revision as of 18:46, 8 January 2023

Bindbole Wood was a small wood in the southern part of the Northfarthing in the Shire.[1]

Etymology[edit | edit source]

The name presumably contains bind and bole "trunk of a tree".[2]

Misspelling[edit | edit source]

The name appears in the map of the Shire, but the letter o in the 1954 edition was not very clear; thus the name has been rendered Bindbale in many later maps (e.g. by Barbara Strachey and Karen Wynn Fonstad), and elsewhere, like in Robert Foster's The Complete Guide to Middle-earth (s.v. Bindbale).

Even Tolkien himself referred to Bindbale in a manuscript note when he was preparing the document later known as Nomenclature (Hammond and Scull suggest that perhaps writing this, Tolkien referred to the printed map and fell victim too of the misprinted o); as a result, in dutch it was translated (after Tolkien's suggestion) as Pakkebaal Bos which includes baal "bale".[3][3]

Inspiration[edit | edit source]

Christopher Tolkien would reminisce that there is an actual English place named "Bindbole Wood", being one of the real place-names borrowed while drawing A Part of the Shire map with his father. However this must be a false memory as there is no trace of such a place, not even Christopher himself was able to find any information afterwards.[3]

References