Letter to Peter Alford (February 1956)
- Subject: Tolkien gives details of the titles considered for the six books of The Lord of the Rings.
- Publication: Excerpts appeared in Sotheby's Valuable Printed Books and Manuscripts 13 December 2001.
Pieter Collier has noted that Peter Alford was a bookbinder, who had written to Tolkien asking for permission to bind his Lord of the Rings set with his own sub-titles. Tolkien approved but also detailed his preferred titles:
I think your own choices may stand. The only real divisions are, of course, the 'books'. It may interest you to know what the titles were to have been, before the decision to publish in three parts.
I The First Journey (the Ring sets out.)
II The Journey of the Nine Companions (the Ring goes South)
III The Treason of Isengard
IV The Journey of the Ringbearer (the Ring goes east)
V The War of the Ring
VI The End of the Third Age
The alternative or sub-titles in brackets would have been abandoned, I think."
Alford's set (sold by Sotheby's for GBP 32,450 in December 2001) included the following note by Tolkien:
"The titles of the six Books, the only proper division of The Lord of the Rings were those originally devised before its publication in three parts. Peter Alford has my approval of his own choice of sub-titles on his bindings. J.R.R. Tolkien".
- Letter to Peter Alford (14 January 1956)
- Letter to Peter Alford (1956-58)
- Letter to Peter Alford (2 April 1958)
- Christina Scull and Wayne G. Hammond (2006), The J.R.R. Tolkien Companion and Guide: I. Chronology, p. 485
- "Valuable Printed Books and Manuscripts. 2001", TolkienBooks.net (accessed 26 May 2014)
- Pieter Collier, "The amazing art of bookbinding - The Lord of the Rings - Part 2" dated 25 January 2011, Tolkien Library (accessed 25 May 2014)