User talk:80.132.228.127: Difference between revisions

From Tolkien Gateway
(Added reply)
No edit summary
Line 4: Line 4:


::I'm sure you had good intentions but you simply can't post the family tree on every single page, it is not relevant enough. However I've added the link to [[Eldar]] and [[Atani]] which are relevant. If the family tree was oriented around a specific character, let's say [[Aragorn II]], and the visitor clicks the link they would have a very hard time even finding Aragorn on the tree, so it is useless for them. Your link is also broken at the moment so please fix that. Otherwise, great work on the tree. --[[User:Hyarion|Hyarion]] 11:01, 15 August 2006 (EDT)
::I'm sure you had good intentions but you simply can't post the family tree on every single page, it is not relevant enough. However I've added the link to [[Eldar]] and [[Atani]] which are relevant. If the family tree was oriented around a specific character, let's say [[Aragorn II]], and the visitor clicks the link they would have a very hard time even finding Aragorn on the tree, so it is useless for them. Your link is also broken at the moment so please fix that. Otherwise, great work on the tree. --[[User:Hyarion|Hyarion]] 11:01, 15 August 2006 (EDT)
:::Ok, maybe you´re right. [[Eldar]] and [[Atani]] are surely the right places - I just don´t think that it is such difficult to find any charakter you like. Surely, for Tolkien-newbies it is useless. But this tree isn´t made for newbies ;)
Of course, maybe I should have asked before; I didn´t, because it has never been a problem in other encyclopedias.
The link is broken? I can´t see any problems... {{unsigned|80.132.228.127}}

Revision as of 15:23, 15 August 2006

I thought I would be nice before and let you add the links but you've pushed your luck. Please find somewhere else to advertise. --Hyarion 10:01, 15 August 2006 (EDT)

Advertise? Whats wrong with my link? Its just a familytree Unsigned comment by 80.132.228.127 (talk • contribs).
I'm sure you had good intentions but you simply can't post the family tree on every single page, it is not relevant enough. However I've added the link to Eldar and Atani which are relevant. If the family tree was oriented around a specific character, let's say Aragorn II, and the visitor clicks the link they would have a very hard time even finding Aragorn on the tree, so it is useless for them. Your link is also broken at the moment so please fix that. Otherwise, great work on the tree. --Hyarion 11:01, 15 August 2006 (EDT)
Ok, maybe you´re right. Eldar and Atani are surely the right places - I just don´t think that it is such difficult to find any charakter you like. Surely, for Tolkien-newbies it is useless. But this tree isn´t made for newbies ;)

Of course, maybe I should have asked before; I didn´t, because it has never been a problem in other encyclopedias. The link is broken? I can´t see any problems... Unsigned comment by 80.132.228.127 (talk • contribs).