User contributions for 172.68.63.161
From Tolkien Gateway
5 September 2022
- 16:2416:24, 5 September 2022 diff hist +94 Morgoth Undo revision 356451 by 172.68.63.161 (talk) Lost Tales are as much a part of canon as the Lost Road and other Writings where the Turin prophecy is. We cannot just ignore one part of canon and only mention another. The prophecy for Turin is not part of the Silmarillion/Unifinshed Tales/Lord of the Rings Trilogy. It only appears on History of Middle Earth where the Eonwe prophecy also appears. Therefore both must be added. Tag: Undo
- 16:1216:12, 5 September 2022 diff hist −92 Morgoth Undo revision 356450 by 172.68.63.107 (talk) Tag: Undo
3 September 2022
- 23:1323:13, 3 September 2022 diff hist +92 Morgoth Undo revision 353789 by LorenzoCB (talk) : Version with Turin comes from the Lost Road and other Writings, which together with The Book of Lost Tales are both part of the same collection The History of Middle Earth. So they are both part of canon and both should be included Tag: Undo
